Did Jonah Die in the Belly of the Whale?

Tessa H. (age 11) asks,

“Did Jonah die in the belly of the whale?”

What a good question!

When we have a question about something the Bible says, the first thing we should do is read the passage carefully to make sure that we understand what it really says and get all of the relevant details. Jonah was thrown overboard during a severe storm that would normally kill someone. Then he was swallowed whole by a fish—that would also normally kill someone. God specially prepared the fish, indicating that something miraculous is happening.

Jonah 2 is Jonah’s prayer “from the belly of the fish” (Jonah 2:1). He uses a lot of death and afterlife language. He says that he cried to God “from the belly of Sheol” (Jonah 2:2). He says, “The waters closed in over me to take my life” (Jonah 2:5), so that might suggest he was dead.

However, David says, “The cords of death encompassed me; the torrents of destruction assailed me; the cords of Sheol entangled me; the snares of death confronted me” (Psalm 18:4–5). That’s very similar language, but Psalm 18 tells us when David wrote it—when God delivered him from Saul. If David used language like that in a situation when he didn’t die, we shouldn’t assume that Jonah died.

In fact, I think that Jonah was a good Bible student. He probably had that psalm, or one of the psalms like it, in mind when he was praying in the fish because the prayer is structured like those psalms. That would indicate that Jonah didn’t die, but only because God saved him.

Another reason to think that Jonah didn’t die inside the fish is that in both the Old Testament and New Testament, God did miracles to bring people back from the dead, and it says so in specific language. But it doesn’t do that in the case of Jonah. God’s deliverance of Jonah was miraculous, but it doesn’t say that it was a resurrection.

Do you have a question about the Bible? Ask your parents to help you submit your question today. We’d love to hear from you!